Critique of Lars Eighners Dumpster Diving Essay Example For Students

Critique of Lars Eighners Dumpster Diving Essay Yesterday, I threw out an old jar of peanut butter with only about an inch of it left. It had not expired yet, but we had gotten a new jar, and that one simply tasted better. I wasnt supporting the homeless community, or being wasteful, I was just trying to make room in the cabinet. If I would have kept that inch of peanut butter, it wouldnt have made the worlds population of homeless people try to find work, nor want to get off the streets. Lars Eighner is suggesting that when we throw away things, homeless people can find a way to make use out of whatever it is. Therefore, if we dont want there to be bums on the street, it is inferred that we shouldnt throw anything extra out if we want to change that. To me, that is simply ridiculous. We all know, that if someone is desperate enough, they can make use out of almost anything, and some of those things non-homeless folk cant use anymore. Were not feeding or clothing the homeless intentionally, we cant help if people dig through our trash. So, not throwing away anything extra is not going to turn the vagabonds of the world into a fine, upstanding, or hard-working citizen of America. Obviously, I completely disagree with Eighners purpose in writing Dumpster Diving. I think the whole thing is preposterous. The way he makes a general assumption about how everybodys is wasteful is pure ignorance. It seem as if he is saying that the reason why people are homeless is because we throwing out things. Eighner is trying to tell us that people will remain homeless until we start saving more and wasting less, but thats not how it works. Most people dont choose to be homeless. Some even start out having their own companies, or just simply having jobs and comfortable live. . out and got a job. He stopped relying on the trash of people, and simply started working. People werent throwing out more or less, he just simply applied himself. Who cares what we throw out, its not going to make a difference. All-in-all, Eighner fails at his attempt to get us to stop wasting what we cant use. It is easy to see that its not our faults if people are homeless, because we are not contributing to that. Removing clutter and getting rid of junk does not keep people on the streets! Some people are just down-and-out, and theres nothing we can do to help or hurt that. Eighner needs to look at the man in the mirror and realize that if he didnt get a job because people cut off their garbage, then thats not the case. Even though Eighner disagrees with me, today, tomorrow, and the day after that, I will always throw away that inch of peanut butter.